Why was Arsenal penalty overturned at Newcastle?

There is never any shortage of controversy when Arsenal play Newcastle at St James’ Park.

The latest talking point came after the Gunners were awarded a 14th-minute penalty during their dramatic 2-1 win, only for the decision to be overturned after an intervention from the video assistant referee (VAR).

A slack backpass from Newcastle’s Jacob Murphy was pounced upon by Arsenal striker Viktor Gyokeres, who was brought down by goalkeeper Nick Pope.

Referee Jarred Gillett pointed to the spot, but when replays suggested Pope had got a touch on the ball, the Australian was sent to the pitchside monitor to have another look.

Gillett agreed and, despite Arsenal’s protests, the penalty decision was reversed.

Making the on-pitch announcement, he said: “After review, the Newcastle goalkeeper plays the ball and there is no foul. The final decision is drop ball.”

While it looked clear Pope got a touch on the ball, was that alone enough to conclude that it was definitely not a penalty?

Here is what the International Football Association Board law says…

A direct free-kick is awarded if a player commits any of the following offences against an opponent in a manner considered by the referee to be careless, reckless or using excessive force:

If an offence involves contact, it is penalised by a direct free-kick.

Former Manchester United defender Gary Neville on Sky Sports: “Viktor Gyokeres kicks it against Nick Pope’s feet. Pope has still blocked Viktor Gyokeres.

“Gyokeres touches the ball and then there is a touch and then he takes him down after that.

“I’m definitely torn. Nick Pope does get a touch and that is usually the barometer for referees and goalkeepers and penalties.”

Former Chelsea midfielder Pat Nevin on BBC Radio 5 Live: “It is not how I saw it. I have to be honest, the VAR has looked at it and the referee has looked at it.

“Yes, he got a touch on it but he still took out the player. But I am looking at it from the forward’s perspective.”

Match of the Day pundit, former Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart: “If Pope touches the ball, then it’s not a penalty – and he does touch it before he hits Gyokeres.

“If you break it down and see why it’s not been given, then you can’t argue with the decision.”

Former Liverpool midfielder Jamie Redknapp on Sky Sports: “He gets a touch but I’m not sure it’s enough to negate the foul. I’m amazed it got overturned.

“Even though he got a touch, he still fouls the player. Gyokores anticipates it, gets away from it and he clears him out. I can see both sides, but I’m surprised it got overturned.”

Former Newcastle striker Les Ferdinand on Sky Sports: “It’s a great touch. When I first saw it, I shouted, ‘I think Pope gets a touch’. He goes through, he does get a touch and as a centre-forward, I probably do want the penalty.

“Once the goalkeeper gets a touch and he deviates the ball, it’s not a penalty. I don’t know what Pope can do there.”

This article is the latest from BBC Sport’s Ask Me Anything team.

Ask Me Anything is a service dedicated to answering your questions.

We want to reward your time by telling you things you do not know and reminding you of things you do.

The team will find out everything you need to know and be able to call upon a network of contacts including our experts and pundits.

We will be answering your questions from the heart of the BBC Sport newsroom, and going behind the scenes at some of the world’s biggest sporting events.

Our coverage will span the BBC Sport website, app, social media and YouTube accounts, plus BBC TV and radio.