Why Joe Humphreys says your Netflix picks and Duolingo streak don’t prove you’re smart

DCM Editorial Summary: This story has been independently rewritten and summarised for DCM readers to highlight key developments relevant to the region. Original reporting by The Irish Times, click this post to read the original article.

If you’ve ever followed a “top 20 must-see” list at a museum, you might understand how it can turn a meaningful cultural experience into a checklist exercise. One visitor to Madrid’s Museo del Prado had this realization after initially focusing only on seeing famous masterpieces, rather than experiencing the art itself. On a later visit, they ignored rankings and let the artwork guide the experience, leaving with a much deeper sense of appreciation.

This shift highlights a concept called “value capture,” explained by philosopher C Thi Nguyen. Value capture happens when you adopt external standards—like rankings or ratings—without questioning them. Nguyen argues that scoring systems can reduce the richness of human experience by simplifying complex decisions into easy metrics. While this may seem harmless in a museum, it becomes more serious in areas like dating, education, and work, where algorithms and rankings heavily influence how people behave and what they value.

The problem with over-relying on data and statistics is that it can override your natural judgment and unique experiences. Nguyen warns that as big data becomes more pervasive, you risk letting numbers shape your identity and choices. However, you can resist this by being more critical of metrics and embracing playfulness—a trait that algorithmic systems can’t quantify. Keep space in your life for curiosity and spontaneity rather than letting scores define you.

A practical step is to identify the metrics that are draining meaning from your life and try to ignore them. Examples include “likes” on social media, daily digital streaks, algorithmic content suggestions, IQ scores, and GDP. These metrics often pretend to offer clarity and objectivity, but they oversimplify reality and can lead to poor judgments. By letting go of these measurements, you give yourself the freedom to live with more intention and authenticity.