Breaking News
Challenge to BusConnects plan expected to be resolved by removal of Malahide Road stop
Read more on post .
The longest-running High Court case against the National Transport Authority’s (NTA) BusConnects programme is expected to be resolved by the removal of a planned bus stop.
An Artane resident in March of last year initiated judicial review proceedings against An Bord Pleanála’s decision to grant permission for the Clongriffin to city centre corridor due to concerns over the location of a bus stop.
The corridor, granted permission by the board in January last year, is one of 12 segregated bus routes planned as part of the €4 billion scheme to transform the capital’s bus services.
Áine Kelly challenged the board’s decision to permit the removal of two existing sheltered bus stops on Malahide Road and to replace them with one unprotected stop outside her home, which is part of a terrace of single-storey cottages with no front gardens.
Ms Justice Emily Farrell said the planning board had “significantly mischaracterised the serious concerns of the resident” about privacy and security at her home and dismissed them as “matters of annoyance or inconvenience”.
Ms Kelly and her neighbours had made several submissions to the NTA during its pre-application consultation process, and to the board during the planning process.
She said she and her neighbours are in favour of the BusConnects project, and the Clongriffin corridor, but opposed to the removal of the two existing stops with shelters and their replacement with an uncovered stop.
The submissions centred on the likelihood that, given there was no space on the footpath for a bus shelter, passengers waiting for the bus would congregate directly outside their homes, blocking windows and doors and compromising privacy and safety.
Buses would run on a 24-hour schedule with up to 30 buses per hour at peak times, the court heard.
In her written judgment this week, Ms Justice Farrell said it required “little imagination” to understand the resident’s submission “as a concern that the adverse impact on their privacy, and their property, including the ability to open windows in their homes, would be worsened by the placing of a bus stop immediately outside” the cottage. This “would necessarily involve the congregating of passengers outside her home”, the judge said.
However, she said neither the board nor the NTA “considered whether an alternative position should or could be found to avoid the consequences” outlined by the resident.
The benefit of addressing the complaints “was not weighed or considered in rejecting the alternatives and preferring the location which had been chosen”.
In dismissing the concerns in relation to the bus stop, the reasons given by the board “were inadequate”, Ms Justice Farrell said. The board’s “mischaracterisation” of the concerns as a matter of “annoyance” was a “failure to understand and correctly characterise the submission of a breach of rights, privacy and security at the dwelling”, which meant “the reason for rejecting the applicant’s submission was legally defective”.
Ms Justice Farrell said she broadly accepted it would be “disproportionate to quash the entire scheme” and has given the parties an opportunity to make further submissions before October 13th.
However, she said the court may decide to amend the board’s decision “for example by maintaining the status quo in relation to one or more adjacent bus stops”.
She made a provisional order quashing the board’s approval of the Artane Cottages stop, pending any submissions.
A spokeswoman for the NTA said “the judgment is still being reviewed and considered”.
Ms Kelly said she did not wish to comment at this time.
Breaking News
UK govt to introduce ‘Brit-Card’ digital identity scheme
Read more on post.
The UK government is set to introduce digital ID cards to tackle illegal migration.
The announcement will be made by Prime Minister Keir Starmer during a speech on Friday, it is understood.
The so-called ‘Brit-Card’ will be subject to consultation and thought to require legislation, as first reported by the Times newspaper.
The scheme will allow the verification of a citizen’s right to live and work in the UK.
Under the plans, anyone starting a new job or looking to rent a home would be required to show the card on a smartphone app.
It would then be checked against a central database of people entitled to live and work in the UK.
It is hoped this would reduce the attraction of working in the UK illegally, including for delivery companies.
This comes amid calls from French President Emmanuel Macron for the UK to reduce “pull factors” for migrants to cross to come to the UK.
A total of 1,157 people have arrived on small boats in the last week, according to Home Office statistics.
Prime Minister Starmer is due to speak at the Global Progress Action Summit in London alongside Australian prime minister Anthony Albanese and Canadian prime minister Mark Carney.
Earlier this month, Mr Starmer said an ID card system could play an “important part” in stopping illegal migration.
He said things had “moved on” since the debate over ID cards during the last Labour government in the 2000s.
He had told the BBC: “We all carry a lot more digital ID now than we did 20 years ago, and I think that, psychologically, it plays a different part.”
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has also previously been positive about the policy.
The UK has only previously had mandatory ID cards during wartime. The last ID scheme was scrapped in 1952.
John Major’s government ran a consultation on reintroducing an ID card scheme in the 1995, but they were never brought in.
His successor, Tony Blair, then considered a voluntary ID card, but it was not fully rolled out amid objections from the Liberal Democrats and Conservatives.
Mr Blair has since called for their introduction.
His calls were backed up by Labour campaign group Labour Together earlier this year which has been closely linked to Mr Starmer and the Government.
The thinktank published a 30-page document in June in favour of the ‘Brit Card’.
In the report, it said: “The Labour government has the opportunity to build a new piece of civic infrastructure, something that would become a familiar feature of daily life for everyone in the country.
“It would support better enforcement of migration rules, and protect vulnerable British citizens from being wrongly denied their rights.”
The civil liberty group Big Brother Watch has again warned against their introduction.
A petition started by the group has reached more than 101,000 signatures.
In a letter to Mr Starmer on Wednesday, the group said: “Mandatory digital ID is highly unlikely to achieve the government’s objective of tackling unauthorised immigration.
“The proposed schemes fundamentally misunderstand the ‘pull factors’ that drive migration to the UK and would do very little to tackle criminal people-smuggling gangs or employers and landlords who operate ‘off the books’.
“Instead, it would push unauthorised migrants further into the shadows, into more precarious work and unsafe housing.”
Ed Davey told the Liberal Democrat conference this week that his party would need to properly “scrutinise” any details, but said it was not necessarily against the policy.
Responding to the ad-hoc poll during an event in Bournemouth, Mr Davey replied: “Times have changed, and that is why I am saying ‘let’s look at it’.”
He added: “There are models that may answer our objections as liberals.”
Breaking News
Barack Obama to be conferred with freedom of Dublin at ceremony on Thursday
Read more on post.
Former US president Barack Obama is set to receive the freedom of the city of Dublin on Thursday.
Mr Obama is visiting the capital this week for a sold-out event at the 3Arena, An Evening with President Barack Obama, In Conversation with Fintan O’Toole on Friday evening.
Details of the ceremony have remained private. It is understood Mr Obama will be conferred with the award in the Shelbourne Hotel on St Stephen’s Green, where Lord Mayor of Dublin Ray McAdam was seen entering on Thursday afternoon.
A crowd formed outside the hotel on hearing speculation of the former US president’s arrival, however he was not seen entering or leaving the building.
Mr McAdam said earlier it was his “firm expectation” Mr Obama would be awarded the city’s highest honour. He said an invitation was extended to the former US president last July, which was recently accepted.
The move has been met with opposition. The Independent Group on Dublin City Council is calling for a boycott, citing Mr Obama’s support for Israel, and his foreign policy interventions in Libya, Yemen, Somalia and elsewhere.
“We call on the Lord Mayor to rescind his offer and, failing that, we ask all invitees to boycott the event,” the group said in a statement on Thursday.
The group comprises Independent councillors Cieran Perry, Nial Ring, John Lyons, Mannix Flynn, Pat Dunne and Kevin Breen.
Speaking to The Irish Times, Mr Flynn said “a lot of councillors are uncomfortable with” Mr Obama receiving the award. He believes the event would be held in public, rather than a private ceremony at the Mansion House, if there was more public support.
Mr Flynn said he doesn’t understand how anyone who is “opposed to the war in Gaza and the genocide in Gaza” could support Mr Obama being given the award.
“The Freedom of the City is something that now is meaningless, absolutely meaningless,” he said.
The councillor said the last time it had any “relevancy” was when Bob Geldof returned his award eight years ago because the honour was bestowed upon Aung San Suu Kyi in 1999. In 2017, Bob Geldof called Myanmar’s then-leader “a handmaiden to genocide” in protest over her response to the persecution and killing of Rohingya Muslims. A month later, Dublin city councillors voted to revoke her award.
Mr Flynn said the council should consider giving Mr Geldof his award back, rather than giving one to Mr Obama.
In 2017, a proposal to award the freedom of the capital to Mr Obama and his wife Michelle faced some similar opposition before being approved by 30 to 23 votes.
It had been proposed by then lord mayor Brendan Carr, who cited the Democrat’s Irish roots and support for peace in Northern Ireland, shortly after he was succeeded by Donald Trump.
The then Labour councillor said while he did not wish to “canonise the Obamas” or declare his presidency “a success”, Mr Obama was a “stabilising and moderating” influence on US foreign policy.
“A similar era, unfortunately, will not be experienced again for some time,” Mr Carr said.
People Before Profit councillor Conor Reddy said over recent weeks that the invitation should be rescinded over the former Democratic president’s support of Israel and military expansion in the Middle East whilst in office.
Breaking News
‘It’s like Pittsburgh invaded Dublin’: NFL fans happy to tick off ‘bucket list’ city
Read more on post .
Within hours of arriving to Ireland for the first time, Pittsburgh native Caley Sanguigni’s most prominent impression is that the Irish “love their swear words like a drunk Pittsburgher”.
“Our Uber driver who took us here was swearing up a storm,” she said.
Standing in Dublin Castle’s upper courtyard, which, for three days, is hosting an National Football League (NFL) festival, she said: “It’s like Pittsburgh invaded Dublin.”
Sanguigni is one of more than 70,000 people due to attend the first ever regular-season NFL game played in Dublin.
Sunday’s Pittsburgh Steelers v Minnesota Vikings clash has drawn a significant number of visitors from the US, which, according to NFL UK and Ireland general manager Henry Hodgson, is not typical for games hosted outside the sport’s homeland.
He cited data based on expressions of interest logged before tickets went on sale earlier this year. A third of those intending to attend were from the US, another third was based in Ireland and the remainder were from the UK and the rest of Europe.
“That is not normally the make-up of those games,” he said.
For other games staged abroad, such as in the UK, he said between 60 and 70 per cent of tickets were typically purchased by locals.
“I think it speaks to Dublin as a bucket list location.”
[ The NFL comes to Dublin: How it became the richest sports league in the worldOpens in new window ]
The NFL stages games abroad with a view to expanding the reach and popularity of “America’s Game”. With the number of Irish NFL fans, and viewership of the sport here, rising in recent years, he expects the occasion to be a “catalyst for further growth”.
Should Sunday’s game have the desired impact, something he said will be measured by the NFL and the Irish Government afterwards, more Irish fixtures could be on the cards.
There have been some high-profile attacks on tourists in Dublin in recent months and years, including a 2023 assault on New York native Stephen Termini, which prompted the US embassy in Dublin to warn visitors to Ireland to keep a “low profile”.
However, Hodgson maintains that Dublin and Ireland are perceived as being “incredibly safe” by US visitors.
The prospect of pro-Palestinian protests on Sunday was not a concern, he said, adding that sport can be a “unifying force” and there will be no attempt to ban any flags at the game, Palestinian or otherwise.
A view of Steelers painted on the Croke Park pitch ahead of Sunday’s game
Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Laszlo Geczo
An Garda Síóchána expects arrangements put in place for the game at Croke Park to cause significant traffic disruption and delays. The force said a “large number” of uniformed gardaí will be deployed, as well specialist units including the public order unit, armed support unit and air support unit.
On Thursday, Dublin’s streets, pubs and tour buses were already awash with the signature black, gold and purple colours of the Steelers and Vikings.
Many of those who had travelled said Dublin felt “welcoming” and “safe” when compared to other European capitals, with almost all expressing shock at the presence of the sun.
An older couple arriving at Dublin Castle were overheard asking a steward how to pronounce “Galway”. That tourist hotspot, as well as the Cliffs of Moher, Killarney and Spike Island in Co Cork, appeared to be on the must-see lists of many of those who have planned extended stays.
Ashley Graf, a Vikings fan from Minnesota, travelled to Dublin with her mother Sherral, saying the country has been on their “bucket list” for some time.
“Win or lose, it’s still fun to be here. Everyone’s been really nice and helpful,” she said.
Sarah Roy, a native of Ottawa, Canada, who came to travel around the island and see the game, said the Irish have a “wonderful reputation” abroad.
“We’ve never heard anything bad about the Irish people and they’ve surpassed expectations,” she said.
Stacey Wilson and her daughter Brittany, from North Carolina, described Ireland as a “completely different world” to what they are used to back home.
“It is expensive, I’m not gonna lie, but we expected that,” she said.
-
Culture2 days ago
Taylor Swift’s new cinema outing generates more than €12million in just 24 hours
-
Politics2 days ago
European Parliament snubs Orbán with vote to shield Italian MEP from Hungarian arrest
-
Culture2 weeks ago
Life, loss, fame & family – the IFI Documentary Festival in focus
-
Health3 days ago
EU renews support for WHO’s Universal Health Coverage Partnership
-
Culture2 months ago
Fatal, flashy and indecent – the movies of Adrian Lyne revisited
-
Culture2 days ago
Twilight at 20: the many afterlives of Stephenie Meyer’s vampires
-
Environment6 days ago
Key oceans treaty crosses threshold to come into force
-
Culture1 week ago
Farewell, Sundance – how Robert Redford changed cinema forever